Many in the media are clobbering Amber Guyger, the officer who accidentally shot her neighbor. I say it was a very bad, sad accident, but she should not be convicted of murder. She was coming off a 14 hour shift, she’s a cop – too often facing danger as she protects and serves, and the facts clearly indicate it was an ACCIDENT. She already has lost her job, and I say that’s enough.
I have known many fine cops and some awful ones. I have had hundreds of trials.
This reminds me of one of the cases very early in my career, in Family Court. For me, the case was a “no brainer” – my job was to be fair, not just to lock up people!
A kid named Paitsel (that was 45 years ago, and I remember the name only because I met his son when I was in prison. At that time, about 10 years ago, it took me a couple of hours to make the connection – “that name, Paitsel, is familiar to me…” ) , age 17, had shot and killed his best friend. The two of them were fooling around in the victim’s basement after school, where there were guns in a cabinet. The defendant got a rifle out, pointed it at the victim, said “bang, you’re dead”, as he pulled the trigger. But before he could say “you’re dead”, his friend began his fall to the floor, for the bullet had gone through his heart. Neither realized the gun was loaded. After talking to young Paitsel – he was devastated, and what good would it do to convict him of it??! – I used my discretion and said to the judge: “Your Honor, the state enters a nolle prosequi”, dropping the charge against the child. The arresting cop was ok with it and that was that.
Today one would need approval from two or three others in the AG’s office before making that decision – ridiculous!
Excerpts from the Article:
A Dallas police officer started to cry and shake Friday as she began to testify about the night she killed a neighbor in his own home, which she has said she mistook for her own unit one floor below.
Amber Guyger broke down while recalling approaching her neighbor Botham Jean’s door, leading the judge to call for a brief break so she could compose herself.
Guyger, who is charged with murder in the killing last September, was the first witness that her lawyers called in the high-profile case. She told jurors about how she grew up in a small house in the Dallas suburb of Arlington, how she played in the school band and how she aspired to become a police officer. “I just wanted to help people and that was the one career that I thought I could help people in,” said Guyger, who was fired from the police force after the shooting.
Guyger’s testimony marked the first time the public has heard directly from the 31-year-old since Jean’s killing last September. Guyger, who is white, was off duty but in uniform when she shot Jean, a 26-year-old native of the Caribbean nation of St. Lucia who was black and worked as an accountant in Dallas.
The basic facts of the unusual shooting are not in dispute. Guyger walked up to Jean’s apartment — which was on the fourth floor, directly above hers on the third — and found the door unlocked. She was off duty but still dressed in her police uniform after a long shift when she shot Jean with her service weapon. Guyger was later arrested, fired and charged with murder.
Guyger’s attorneys say she fired in self-defense after mistaking Jean for a burglar. Her attorneys also say the identical physical appearance of the complex from floor to floor frequently led to tenants parking on the wrong floor or trying to enter the wrong apartment.
Prosecutors have questioned how Guyger could have missed numerous signs that she was in the wrong place, and suggested she was distracted by sexually explicit phone messages with her police partner. Prosecutors also say Jean was no threat to Guyger, noting that he was in his living room eating a bowl of ice cream when she entered his apartment.
In a frantic 911 call played in court earlier this week, Guyger says “I thought it was my apartment” nearly 20 times. The shooting attracted intense national scrutiny for the strange circumstances and because it was one in a chain of shootings of unarmed black men by white police officers.
The trial began Monday.